About this proposal
I'm PJ Kirner, and I live in Greenmeadow in Palo Alto. I'd like to start a free, nonprofit app for giving, asking and lending between neighbors.
Starting and running this will take my time. I'm happy to give it if enough neighbors say they'd use it.
Sharing is also how you meet neighbors, and I hope the app leads to more of that.
Near the bottom of the page, click "I'd join" if you'd use the app, or "I don't think this is a good idea" if you don't.
What's hard today
Many neighbors already give things away through neighborhood email lists, Buy Nothing groups and Nextdoor. Posting is easy. What comes after takes time. For most of us, it's easier to toss something or leave it in the garage than to find a neighbor who wants it.
- Picking who gets it. You read through replies and choose by hand, sometimes after waiting a day or two.
- Arranging pickup. Times, addresses and "is it still there?" go back and forth one message at a time.
- No-shows. When someone can't make it, you go back to the replies and start over.
- Borrowing. Nothing keeps track of who has your ladder or when it's coming back.
What the app does
The app takes care of picking someone, arranging pickup and following up.
Five kinds of posts
- Give. Post a photo and a short description. Neighbors tap "I'm interested." When your waiting time is up, the app picks one of them using the method you set: at random, by hand, or favoring neighbors who haven't received anything lately or who reliably show up.
- Ask to keep. Post something you need, like a crib or moving boxes. Neighbors who have one offer it, and you pick.
- Ask to borrow. Post something you need for a day or two, like a folding table for a party. Offers come in, and the app keeps track of the return date.
- Lending library. List things you're happy to lend again and again, like a long ladder or a pressure washer. They stay listed. Neighbors ask to borrow, and you say yes or no each time.
- On my curb now. Put something at the curb and post a photo. Anyone nearby can just take it.
You choose how it works for your posts
When you sign up, you pick a few settings. They're used for every post, and you can change them on any single post.
- Waiting time: wait 24 or 48 hours so everyone has a fair chance, or give it to the first person who confirms a pickup time.
- How the recipient is picked: at random, by hand from the list, or favoring people who haven't received anything lately or who reliably show up. The app always uses the method you chose.
- Resellers: whether people who might resell your item can get it.
- Who sees your posts: see "Who sees each post" below.
Pickup and no-shows
When the app picks someone, it sends them your pickup details and asks them to confirm within a set time, for example 12 hours.
You set your pickup times once (for example, "porch pickup, weekday evenings"), and the person picks one of them.
If they don't confirm in time, the app moves to the next person in line. If they confirm but don't show up, you tap "didn't show" and it moves on.
Reminders go out before pickup. Afterward you both tap "done," and can send a thank-you note. For loans, the app reminds the borrower before the return date and asks the owner to confirm the item came back.
Your pickup record
The app keeps track of how often each member shows up after being picked. Recent pickups count most, so an old miss fades over time.
Only real no-shows count. Cancelling ahead of time doesn't count against you, and new members start with a clean record.
Givers see a simple label, such as "reliable." They don't see a number. You can always see your own record.
Your history
A "Your history" page lists what you've given, received, lent and borrowed, with dates, and anything still out.
Only you can see it, and you can download it.
Who sees each post
Each time you post, you choose who can see it: just your neighborhood, the neighborhoods next to yours, the whole city, or neighboring cities too.
For example, you might lend your ladder only within your neighborhood, but offer a couch to the whole city so it gets picked up sooner.
Examples
An extra Costco buy. I bought a big box of granola bars at Costco, and it turns out nobody in my family likes them. I could return them, but I'd rather a neighbor had them. I post a photo, choose "my neighborhood," "wait 24 hours," and "pick at random." Five neighbors are interested. The next day the app picks Dana and sends her my porch pickup times. Dana doesn't confirm, so the app moves on to Sam, who picks them up that evening. I tap "done."
Lending the ladder. My ladder is in the lending library, visible to my neighborhood only. A neighbor two streets over asks to borrow it Thursday to Saturday. I say yes, she picks it up, and on Saturday the app reminds her to return it. I confirm it's back, and it stays listed for the next person.
Borrowing for a party. A neighbor needs two folding tables for Sunday and posts "back Monday." Two people offer. She accepts one, and the return reminder goes out Monday.
Something bigger. When we replace our couch, I choose "all of Palo Alto" so more people see it, and the app books a Saturday pickup with whoever it picks.
Trust and privacy
Joining by being vouched for
To join, a neighbor who's already a member vouches for you. Nobody has to upload documents.
Each neighborhood starts with a few people who know each other. After that, any member can invite someone they know with a one-time link.
If you don't know anyone on the app yet, meet a neighbor first, for example at a community event, and ask them to vouch for you. I'd like the app to give people reasons to meet.
One vouch is enough. Members can flag someone who seems not to live nearby. That person then needs a new vouch. People review flags; software doesn't.
Privacy
- Your address stays private. Others see only your neighborhood until a pickup is agreed, and then only that one person sees your address.
- You don't have to meet anyone. If you'd rather not, choose porch pickup and leave the item outside.
- No passwords. You sign in with a link sent to your email.
- Very little data. The app keeps only what it needs to arrange handoffs. No ads, and your data is never sold.
Rules
- Everything is free: no selling, trading, prices or ads.
- Nothing illegal.
- Post asks publicly, not by private message. People can message each other only once they're matched for a handoff.
- Posting for a friend or family member is fine. Mention it in the post.
- Be respectful, and say plainly what you're offering or asking for.
- The app doesn't check items or guarantee handoffs. You're responsible for what you give, take and lend.
Before a post goes live, an automated check looks for likely rule breaks, such as a price or a business ad, and lets the poster fix it. It never removes a post or bans anyone by itself. People make those calls.
Paying for it: nonprofit, no ads
The app would be run as a nonprofit and paid for by donations.
- Free for everyone, with nothing locked behind payment.
- No ads, and no selling data.
- Donating is optional and never affects how you're treated in the app.
- A simple yearly page shows what came in and what it paid for.
Running costs for one neighborhood should be small: servers, email, and the automated post checks.
Frequently asked questions
These are the questions I expect, with my current answers. The answers are proposals, so please comment on them too.
How is this different from Buy Nothing, Nextdoor or Freecycle?
This app does the follow-up for you: it picks someone by the method you set, arranges the pickup, and moves on after a no-show. It also handles lending, which the others mostly don't.
You can keep using what you use today.
There are already too many apps. Why another one?
I agree there are a lot. It's only worth building if it's clearly easier than what you do now, and I'd like you to tell me whether it would be.
It's only useful if my neighbors are on it too. What if nobody joins?
It would start small: one neighborhood, beginning with a trial of 30 to 50 households in my neighborhood, Greenmeadow, who invite people they know. Because a post can reach the whole city, early posts still find people while the neighborhood fills up.
I like choosing who gets my things. Will the app pick for me?
Only if you want it to. Picking by hand is one of the choices.
Do I have to give my home address?
Yes, because it's where pickups happen and it decides your neighborhood. It's never shown publicly. Others see only your neighborhood, and only the person picking up from you sees your address.
I'm new here and don't know anyone. Isn't vouching cliquey?
I hope not. Meeting one neighbor is enough: knock on a door or come to a community event, and ask them to vouch for you.
What if something I lend gets broken or isn't returned?
You decide what you lend and to whom, and you can see the borrower's pickup record. Return dates and reminders are built in, and you can block someone who doesn't return things. Lending is at your own risk, as it is when you lend to a neighbor today.
I don't want software reading my posts.
The automated check only looks at public posts, only for clear rule breaks like prices or ads. It never removes a post or bans anyone by itself, and it doesn't read private messages.
Will it cost anything? Will there be ads?
No to both. It's free, paid for by donations, and never sells your data.
What happens if it shuts down?
I'll keep costs low and publish the finances. You can also download your own data, so nothing is lost if it closes.
Will there be a phone app?
Yes, the plan is phone apps plus a website, with notifications by email as well.
An idea for later: what the neighborhood shares together
This is an idea for later, not part of the first version. I'd like to know whether you think it's worth having.
Each handoff is between two people, so nobody sees the total. A community page would show it: things given, asks answered, loans made and returned, and how many neighbors took part, for your neighborhood and your whole city.
A short monthly or yearly report would give the same numbers, for example "this month our neighborhood gave away 84 things and lent 23," and could also go to your neighborhood email list.
Both would show totals only. They would never show who gave or got what.
Questions I'd like your input on
- Would you use it? For giving, asking, borrowing, lending, or all four?
- Should "on my curb now" posts be allowed?
- Would a monthly report of what the neighborhood shared be welcome, or just more email?
- What should be banned beyond illegal items?
- How should flags for "doesn't seem to live here" work, so they're fair and not misused?
- What would stop you from using it?
How to comment
Please comment on anything you like or don't like, or anything you think is missing. Nothing has been built yet, so now is when your ideas can change it most.
To comment on a specific part, select some text (on a phone, press and hold) or tap a number like 4.2¶1. Your comment comes straight to me, along with the part of the page you picked. Adding your name and email helps, but you can stay anonymous.
If you think this won't work, or isn't needed, please say so. I'd much rather hear it now than start something the neighborhood doesn't want.
What happens next
If enough neighbors say they'd use it, I'll build it and start with a small trial in my neighborhood, Greenmeadow. If enough neighbors say it's a bad idea, I'll respect that and spend my time on something else.
That's why both buttons ask for your name and email: so each answer comes from a real neighbor.
I'll keep this page up to date as the plan changes, so you can see what your comments changed.
12 Would you join?
If you'd use this, tell me. It's the best way to show the idea has support, and it puts you on the list for the first trial. Your email is only used to tell you about the trial, and is never shared.
If you think it won't work, or isn't needed, please say that too. Honest doubts are just as valuable as support: I'd much rather hear it now than spend months building something the neighborhood doesn't want.
Either answer needs your name and email, so each one comes from a real neighbor. Only I see them; this page shows only the count. You can change your answer any time.
13 Vote on a name
The app needs a name. Pick the one you like best. One vote per household (internet connection), and you can change it any time.
Suggest another name
14 General comments
Anything at all: whether you'd use it, what worries you, what's missing. Comments on a specific part are even more helpful: select text above, or tap its number.